I've never found Tom Cruise anything but saccharin in looks, talent, charisma, personality and performance. Schindlers List was one of the most moving and brilliant films I've ever seen in my life. Utterly brilliant on all levels.
And whilst on the subject of Nazis, have you seen the film Conspiracy made for the BBC? Kenneth Brannagh et al also giving chilling performances that stay with you for a long time after.
I'll be passing on the Tom Cruise film - what's the point?
Tom Cruise can't get over his Tomcruisiness, he will always be Tom Cruise no matter in which role. Stauffenberg is way over his head, not because he's a scientologist but because it's simply overwhelming his acting talent.
But there is also a large gap between Schindler and Stauffenberg. Schindler may have initially been somewhat Nazi-friendly, but Stauffenberg was a full-on true blood Nazi, you don't get to become general for nothing. It's a whole different story, one tries to save innocent lifes, the other tries to murder a despot and fails in an epic way (heroes of epic failure are a really big german theme, by the way, from the times when Germany was a land of "poets and philosophers" and not what it is today). Was Stauffenberg even an anti-fascist? I think both movies can't be compared, neither can Schindler or Stauffenberg.
Linda Grant is a novelist and journalist. She won the Orange Prize for Fiction in 2000 and the Lettre Ulysses Prize for Literary Reportage in 2006. She writes for the Guardian, Telegraph and Vogue. Her latest novel, The Clothes on Their Backs was shortlisted for the 2008 Man Booker Prize. For further information including upcoming literary festivals bookstore readings etc see her website at www.lindagrant.co.uk
The People on the Street (Winner of the Lettre Ulysses Prize for Literary Reportage 2006)
Still Here (Fiction 2002)
When I Lived in Modern Times (Winner of the Orange Prize for Fiction 2000)
Remind Me Who I Am Again (Non-fiction 1998)
The Cast Iron Shore (Fiction 1996)
Sexing the Millenium (Non-Fiction 1993)
This blog believes
'A good handbag makes the outfit.'
'Only the rich can afford cheap shoes'
'The only thing worse than being skint is looking as if you're skint.'
'A new dress is a great help in all circumstances.' (Noel Streatfeild)
'The only true and lasting meaning of the struggle for life lies in the individual, in his modest peculiarities and his right to these peculiarities.' (Vasily Grossman, Life and Fate.)
5 comments:
Tom looks likes like he's doing a costume test for "The Producers"
I've never found Tom Cruise anything but saccharin in looks, talent, charisma, personality and performance. Schindlers List was one of the most moving and brilliant films I've ever seen in my life. Utterly brilliant on all levels.
And whilst on the subject of Nazis, have you seen the film Conspiracy made for the BBC? Kenneth Brannagh et al also giving chilling performances that stay with you for a long time after.
I'll be passing on the Tom Cruise film - what's the point?
Tom Cruise can't get over his Tomcruisiness, he will always be Tom Cruise no matter in which role.
Stauffenberg is way over his head, not because he's a scientologist but because it's simply overwhelming his acting talent.
But there is also a large gap between Schindler and Stauffenberg. Schindler may have initially been somewhat Nazi-friendly, but Stauffenberg was a full-on true blood Nazi, you don't get to become general for nothing.
It's a whole different story, one tries to save innocent lifes, the other tries to murder a despot and fails in an epic way (heroes of epic failure are a really big german theme, by the way, from the times when Germany was a land of "poets and philosophers" and not what it is today).
Was Stauffenberg even an anti-fascist?
I think both movies can't be compared, neither can Schindler or Stauffenberg.
No one under 5"9 should leave the house wearing baggy breeches.
This Stauffenberg guy only fell out with Hitler when he started losing, didn't he? And Tom Cruise - I agree, what's the point?
Post a Comment